Clue: Element of surprise in this puzzle's theme answers

Answer: TIN

Length: 3

---

Similar Clues:

• Surplus integral to this puzzle's theme answers (EXCESS with 6 letters)
• New element whose name will be ratified in January, 2010, and whose symbol appears in the middle of this puzzle's theme answers (COPERNICIUM with 11 letters)
• Shade from the sun that's inserted in this puzzle's theme answers (TAN with 3 letters)
• Choice words swapped in this puzzle's theme answers (ANDOR with 5 letters)
• New element in each of this puzzle's theme answers (ANO with 3 letters)
• Phrase indicating slight progress, and a hint to this puzzle's theme (ATOB with 4 letters)
• ___ to school . . . or a hint to the puzzle theme suggested by the ends of five answers (BACK with 4 letters)
• It's soft, strong, and demonstrated by this puzzle's four theme answers (BEARHUG with 7 letters)
• Postseason gridiron game, and a hint to the puzzle theme found in starred answers (BOWL with 4 letters)
• Informal chat, and based on the starts of the starred answers, this puzzle's title (BULLSESSION with 11 letters)